MSNBC Apologizes After Accidentally Telling the Truth About Israel

October 27, 2015   |   admintam

Before MSNBC’s apology, pro-Palestinian activists praised the segment as a rare instance of mainstream media honesty about Israeli occupation.

Kit O’Connell
October 27, 2015

(MINTPRESS) New York, NY — Earlier this month, MSNBC aired a well-known, but controversial graphic that illustrates how Israel has taken over Palestine as the occupation of the region has grown over time.

MSNBC_Map_Cropped

The graphic, which appeared during an Oct. 15 discussion between MSNBC anchor Kate Snow and Martin Fletcher, a Middle East correspondent, shows a series of four maps dating from 1946 to the present that depict the loss of Palestinian territory to Israel.

During the segment, Fletcher discussed the ways that Israel’s provocative behavior at Al-Aqsa Mosque is a major trigger for the latest violence in Gaza and the West Bank, then Snow introduced the graphic as it appeared on screen, saying: “What does that show you, Martin, that the area Palestinians are living, has it grown increasingly smaller?”

Fletcher replied:

“Well, absolutely, it’s all about the land, and what this map shows you, and I must say it’s pretty shocking when you present it in this way, what it clearly shows is that, if there’s no peace agreement between the Palestinians and Israel … more of that Palestinian land will be eaten up by Jewish settlements.”

Watch Kate Snow and Martin Fletcher discuss the graphic of Palestine on MSNBC:

Supporters of Palestinian human rights on social media praised what they saw as a rare example of honesty about the occupation from TV news. But some media critics, and especially the Israeli media, criticized the segment, calling the graphic inaccurate. The Jerusalem Post referred to the image, which closely resembled a similar graphic widely circulated among activists, as “a map commonly used by Palestinian propaganda groups,” adding:

“It claimed that in 1946, present-day Israel was under Palestinian rule, leaving out the fact that it was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948, when the British Mandate came to an end.

Another mistake came in the 1947 map which the graphic referred to as the ‘UN plan.’ This was inaccurate for the fact that the supposed 1947 borders never existed, since the UN’s partition plan was rejected by all Arab countries.”

On Oct. 19, MSNBC aired an apology in which Snow called the maps “not factually accurate.” Fletcher also appeared and acknowledged that although there was no internationally recognized country called “Palestine” in 1947, twice as many Arabs as Jews lived in the region at that time.

Watch Kate Snow and Martin Fletcher’s on-air apology on MSNBC:

The Institute for Middle East Understanding defended the map on Thursday, arguing that it “accurately depicts the land that has been forcibly taken from Palestinians since 1946, two years before Israel was established and the accompanying expulsion of between 750,000 and a million Palestinians to make way for a Jewish state.”

And although the country of Palestine was not recognized by the British, who occupied the region in 1947, the non-profit, writing for the website Mondoweiss, noted:

“Palestine as a political entity existed prior to the formation of the state of Israel in 1948, going back to ancient times when it was a province of the Roman empire until more recently when it was British Mandatory Palestine, immediately preceding Israel’s creation.​​”

The institute also acknowledged that the map contained some factual errors, however, including incorrect labelling of the occupied Golan Heights, which Israel has claimed since the Six Day War in 1967, and that “[t]he map also shows ‘Israel’ existing in 1946. While British Mandatory Palestine did exist in 1946, there was no political entity called ‘Israel’ until 1948.”


This article (MSNBC Apologizes After Accidentally Telling the Truth About Israel) originally appeared on MintPressNews.com and was used with permission. Anti-Media Radio airs weeknights at 11pm Eastern/8pm Pacific. If you spot a typo, email edits@theantimedia.org.

Author: admintam

Follow us on Instagram @TheAntiMedia

Share This Post On

116 Comments

  1. ON ISREAEL-PALESTINE MAP: I'd seen a similar set of maps before. Which part is wrong? Show the accurate map then.

    Post a Reply
  2. So who approved the maps? Either they are grossly stupid reporters or they put their foot in their own mouths and expect the viewer to not see it.

    Post a Reply
  3. I am sure that all Americans that support this….would be happy to give up their house (without compensation) to native Americans. They should also support giving 93% of the country back to native Americans(without compensation) and will gladley move into an overcrowded ghetto,surrounded by walls and guns…without comnplianing at all.

    Post a Reply
  4. I have no interest in maps from the 40s. The Palestinians are a hopeless gang of troublemaking thugs. They cannot govern or be governed. Fuck them all.

    Post a Reply
  5. That's a great point. In addition though, to make it a fair analogy, Americans would also have to continually encroach on present reservations, shrinking their size ever more.

    Post a Reply
  6. That's a great point. In addition though, to make it a fair analogy, Americans would also have to continually encroach on present reservations, shrinking their size ever more.

    Post a Reply
  7. the first map is wrong.. there was no palesinian land there… it was a brithis colony.. the rest is more or less ok.. but as a result of wors that the palestinian have started.. they start loos and complane.. well… mmm

    Post a Reply
  8. the first map is wrong.. there was no palesinian land there… it was a brithis colony.. the rest is more or less ok.. but as a result of wors that the palestinian have started.. they start loos and complane.. well… mmm

    Post a Reply
  9. in adition there is no and was no palestinians… who are they ?? what is the history books colture ecc… ??? they are arab imigrants like the one that are coming to europe now.. the difference is that they came to the brithish colony for work.. and ufter a while they start colling themselfs palestinians.. mmmm ok… so they are a nation.. if they say so..

    Post a Reply
  10. Not a good thing to say about a people, whatever our sentiments. Many of us have sympathy for Israel, but when you are confronted with a comment like my Palestinian colleague in the US in the 1980s gave (Ore, you finish school and go to your home, your contry. Where do I go?) you are bound to see the Palestinian plight too. Nobody considers the prospect of being homeless. What do we do to give peace a chance? Definetly, our insults, tirades, …dont help a bit.

    Post a Reply
  11. Stefan Jovanović well thats exactly what they did……just that they did it between 1 and 350 years ago. Encroaching on Native territories, constantly making up treaties that called a halt to expansion and "guaranteed" native land rights….then went ahead and took over the land anyway. Israel's illegal occupation is almost an exact carbon copy of the take over of Native American lands

    Post a Reply
  12. Simone Uomorosso no it wasn't a "British colony", it was a British mandate, assigned after the fall of the Ottoman empire after WW1. It was called the British Mandate of Palestine……so there actually was land bearing the name of "Palestine" in 1946…….there was no land called Israel though

    Post a Reply
  13. Please take your child to the nearest adoption agency, you have no business trying to shape the mind of another person.

    Post a Reply
  14. Simon Uomorrosa. You really are one of the most ignorant people. Britain briefly had a mandate over Palatine after the defeat and collapse of the Ottoman Empire in WW1. The land was occupied by Palastinians as it has been for thousands of years they didn't suddenly immigrate there to get jobs off the British, you stupid plank.

    Post a Reply
  15. This is the norm in the Jew-controlled US media: ANY REFERENCE to the continuing half century of Israeli genocide upon the Palestinians ABSOLUTELY FORBIDDEN. The US government has also been hijacked by Jews/Israel, with a hugely disproportionate amount of Congress consisting of Jews with dual Israeli/US citizenship, and the remainder bought or cowed into submission by AIPAC. The US economy has been utterly devastated by the criminal Jewish banking cartel, known as the Federal Reserve, bailing out "too big to fail" Jewish banks with US taxpayer money. After the imminent, complete economic collapse of the USA, things are going to get a lot more radical, when the sheeple finally wake up and take back their country. Three words for the Jews: "Arbeit macht frei!".

    Post a Reply
  16. All u ppl are retards Palestine been there since biblical times thats where easter came from when Jesus walks in to Jerusalem open a bible there a map. Secondly since the ww1 and ever since I remember they been fights over that land. since It works for Israel aswell US their been working together to strip that land away from them

    Post a Reply
  17. The correction they've made is accurate and correct. Even if it doesn't suit your preconceived ideas.

    Post a Reply
  18. Stefan Jovanović To make it even more fair, we would have to have Native Americans performing terrorist acts against Americans, as the Palestinians have continuously done.

    Post a Reply
  19. Ouch ! I guess that being presented with the visual truth really hurts !! Hear that big slurping sound? It's the last of Palestine being eaten away by American, European and Russian jews. All the land, all the water, all thefairness. The jews never have, do not now, and will not in the future give the Palestineans their own country. They will steal ALL OF IT !!

    Post a Reply
  20. James William Junior Because they are Palestinians and they already have a land that is currently stolen by Israelis!!

    Rikki Cairns, well said buddy!!

    Post a Reply
  21. It is called the 6 day war…1967…..more land was lost during that war…..once again initiated by Arab aggression. Start a war…lose land, then it is your own fault, don't cry about it. Your lucky Israel it is the Roman Empire. They would have just slaughtered you all until there was no more grievances or complaining.

    Post a Reply
  22. Oka crisis 1991, 7 nations tribe in Canada called terrorists for defending their land. Military answered with tanks, gas, and guns. All over the expansion of a golf course.

    Post a Reply
  23. My thought is though that kind of counteracts this being an imoral thing is that over 60% of jews in Israel today are sherpherdy ie. lived in arab ruled territory before 1948 & not european. When the state of Israel was declared in 1948. Every arab state told them they had their own state and they should get the fuck out of egypt, jordan, etc… It's kind of stupid to have a go at them for taking the arabs land, when all their land was taken by arabs elsewhere. I admit palestine gets screwed but it's as much by other arab states as israel, and far more by there own leaders. We just expect far higher standards from israel I suppose.

    I still fucking hate Netanyahu. He's a racist, extremist piece of turd. He treats black ethiopian jews about as well as he treats arabs.

    Post a Reply
  24. Nick Jones yeah the kind of "constant" terrorism palestinian do to israelies hahaha look at the death from both side and do some reseach to see who s the real terrorist also look at the definition of terrorism. look at the life they both have to live with. the rich settler against the poor indegenous. hahaha nick jones you start to do some research your fact are premade by zionst groups.

    Post a Reply
  25. Typical zionist. I think you're the one who's lucky Hitler is no longer alive.

    Post a Reply
  26. Darren Mulholland Well there is now. People better just get used to it. Arabs live in Israel (Arab-Israelis), but people throw a fit if Israelis move into "Palestinian Territories". At the end of the day, the stronger side will always prevail. That's how it's always been for centuries. The winning side of the two competing for land always obtains the land.

    Post a Reply
  27. Palestine never had that land cause is was a British colony? In other words: Palestinians have been taken over long before the 1947 UN deal. The bankers engineered both world wars in order to set up the UN, then used it to create Israel.

    Post a Reply
  28. Palestine is nothing but the name for a geographic region, not a nation, not a people, not ever.

    The Kingdoms of Israel and Judah haven't existed since circa 700BC~. They'd been conquered by the Assyrians, the Babylonians, the Persians, Alexander The Great, The Romans, The Islamic Empire, The Crusaders, The Ottoman Empire, the Egyptians, The British…and finally we have what we have where the powers that be had decided via mandate to declare a nation for a people in diaspora and one of those peoples became the modern nation of Israel.

    The Arabs in the region rejected the initial proposal by the powers that be for the partition of Palestine as they have rejected further peace negotiations with Israel that would have resulted in a nation for "Palestinians." I quote "Palestinians," because it is not and never has been a nationality.

    The people who identify as Palestinians have squandered many opportunities for peace and nationhood.

    Post a Reply
  29. My Uncle Carson got a new gold Hyundai Tucson SUV just by some parttime working online with a macbook… see here now
    ➤➤➤➤➤➤ w­­­­­­w­­­­­­w­­­­­­.­C­­­­a­­­­s­­­­­­­­h­­­­­­­­w­­­­i­­­­k­­­­i­­­­77­­.­­­­­­c­­­­­­o­­­­­­m………….W­­o­­r­­k ­­A­­t­­ H­­o­­m­­e
    Copy&Paste This Link

    Post a Reply
  30. Too bad Hitler didn't finish the job. Would have been a better world. He knew you are all snakes and deserved to get baked in ovens.

    Post a Reply
  31. The day will come when the U.S. Will not support Israel. Nothing lasts forever. Look at history. Babylon fell apart, the Egyptians fell apart, the Romans fell apart, the U.S. Won't always be the great power. And when that happens Israel will disappear off the map with all its fake Zionists with it. The whole world hates Israelis and Israel expect for the U.S. Only a matter of time 🙂

    Post a Reply
  32. This is what Israel does! You think the Arab world wouldn't be defeat a cowardly temporary state called Israel in the 60's? Lol even a freedom fighting army like hezbollah defeated u in 2006, they kicked ur ass out of Lebanon. in the 67 war it was a 'pre-emptive' attack mean Israel started the aggression. Israel have a neutral view on the Syria war, wtf it's right next door! It's cos Israel created this with the help of mummy uk and daddy USA to destabilise Iraq and Syria so when Isis got power they would once again cry 'rape' and attack then occupy that territory and eventually it'll become greater Israel (promised land). Zionists are the worse of humans, lower than shit. They target pregnant women and kids, they are the biggest pussies the world has seen, they will happy bomb civilian areas with a one tonne bomb from the air but will not fight on the ground like real men and when they do on the rare occasions they get slaughtered!

    Post a Reply
  33. I am getting paid $85 hourly for working an online job. I never thought I can do it but my best friend is making $10000 a month by working this job and she showed me what she does. Try it out on following website, you have nothing to lose…

    ►►► ­­­­w­­­w­­w­­­.­­­N­­o­­­t­­e­­­9­­0­­­.­­c­­­o­­m­­­­­­­ONLY

    Please remove the word "ONLY"

    @)_=

    Post a Reply
  34. Joni Schoroth Don't label me. I am not a Zionist. I just call things how I see them. Both sides of this conflict have hands that have drawn blood. Wake up. It is easy to control you, if the elites have us divided.

    Post a Reply
  35. When does your time begin to matter?
    In 1946? In 1850?
    Or in the ancient times when there is no doubt a Jewish state existed?
    If you like to compare the Americans' occupation of the natives' lands, then bear in mind the Americans have never had a land there before. They just killed and occupied land from the poor and weak natives.

    The truth is that the majority of the Arabs in Israels' land have immigrated there from surrounding arab countries, because there was more economical opportunities following Ottomans, British and Jewish activity there.
    The Arabs in israel have rejected all the partition offers and plans, even the ones which greatly favoured them in size and the only thing they accepted is zero Jewish land.
    As a matter of fact, they were attacking Jewish who were allowed to immigrate to Israel by the British. The British allocated yearly immigration amount for Jewish and Arabs Seperately (the Arabs received a much bigger slot, even though they had no historic connection to the land). The Arabs attacked those immigrated Jewish immediately.

    Post a Reply
  36. If Israel handed these animals a state, there would be a civil war w help from several terrorist entities. It would be another Syria.

    Post a Reply
  37. James. Good question. No Arab country wants any part of them. The Palestinians have no leadership which makes them an ungovernable gang. They voted for Hamas while blaming Israel for their problems. Hopeless group of thugs. No leadership but they want everything. Billions of dollars missing. Turned down one peace deal after another. Hopeless people.

    Post a Reply
  38. I mean it did happen to Native Americans, U.S. Citizens should be glad we are peaceful people and not at war. Luckily we aren't in Trump's radar, not yet at least.

    Post a Reply
  39. The Palestinians will continue to suffer until they overthrow hamas and Abbas. When there is legitimate leadership, there is hope.

    Post a Reply
  40. Randy Wilson you are the hopeless one , it is clear that israel/ jews have control over heads of arab countries and the whole world, so how can they accept palestinians ? everyone want his own safety . that's the world .

    Post a Reply
  41. Israel/jews have control over the heads of Arab countries? And the entire world?

    Post a Reply
  42. Stefan Jovanovic, I'm sure if what is happening to the Palestinian people were happening to you and yours, you would have no problem retaliating against terrorists with terrorism. What Israel is doing is despicable and you have to blind to not see that.

    Post a Reply
  43. Stefan Jovanović We are STILL encroaching, by allowing corporations to drill, dig, or whatever on Indian land or around the borders of Indian land, thereby polluting said land.

    Post a Reply
  44. Sean Reilly Just because something sounds racist/anti-semetic, doesn't automatically make it false.

    Post a Reply
  45. Randy Wilson eeh Israelis live on world benefits literally and a stolen land!!! Not to mention the billions you talk about are blocked by your filthy kind !! Are we forgetting $3 billion support to Israel every year supper hasbara dumbhead??

    And people learn nothing from the story of Moses. Pharaoh had it all back then, yet at the end he was dumped and drowned. Winning now doesn't mean winning at all!! P.S. Israel still has to have it all first idiots! Then your end will start with them getting it all!!

    Post a Reply
  46. i propose white european zionist get the fuck out of the land of palestine and go make Israhell in midland KANSAS , or KENTUCK in the U.S . OR GO BACK TO EUROPE , my mom was jewish and she never acept a free apartment on someone else land like the state of ISRRAEL offers to THAT plague to come and populate PALESTINE .ZIONIST ARE WORST THAN NAZIS but u dont have to take my word for it ,just pay attention and see what happens.

    Post a Reply
  47. Hmmmm, but I wonder if MSNBC thought to tell the reason why Israel has gained so much land….the result of wars and violence aimed towards their destruction. I would imagine they "conveniently" forgot that part.

    Post a Reply
  48. Poor Israel lobby — it's got to be really frustrating when your own media propagandists screw up like this.

    >:-(

    Post a Reply
  49. It baffles me that so many people don't know history. Jews have lived in Israel for 3000 years. Longer then Christianity and Islam existed by a millennium. Palestine has been ruled by numerous empires bringing in all types of Arabs from around the region as slaves free people etc etc if you were to do a DNA test on a "Palestinian" I guarantee you could trace that DNA back to a neighboring Arab country. If you did the same test on a Sephardic Jew you would find that they have been in Israel for the last 3000 fucking years. Just because Jews turned a desert waste land into the only democratic country in the region as well as turned it into an economic power house and oasis all of a sudden they want "their" land back. I call bull Shit. Let the anti semetic comments commence. Thank you.

    Post a Reply
  50. I'd be happy if you ll kind of went back where your families originated from,,,,

    Post a Reply
  51. Darren Mulholland they are still doing it,, let's be straight about this.

    Post a Reply
  52. Sean Reilly Stating facts is not racist. If the facts make a race look bad then so be it… Wealthy Jewish people ARE sponsoring the destruction of the entire middle-east………. Jerusalem will be theirs and the murders and the 1% believe the manipulative take over is righteous because it is motivated by religion…. Do what we say—–not what we do……. signed- America … P.s. Muslims motivated by religion are all terrorists … but not Jewish people because they have the power to manipulate the media … hypocrites

    Post a Reply
  53. Sorry, but this is less than half a story. If you don't address that 5 Arab armies attacked Israel when Israel declared a state AND refused the partition plan, you ignore huge events that set the course of history. The Arabs created their own naqba, which they foolishly repeated in 1967 and in 1973. I won't even start with education lesson of "no Palestine government, belonging to Transjordan, no currency, etc.". Or, that the Arab world confiscated Jewish property that far exceeds the size of Israel and killed or expelled over a million Jews from their countries. With nowhere to go, guess what??? They moved to Israel. The Arabs continue to cause their own problems and blame everyone else. The Palestinians are just another pawn and failure in their game. So sad. Idiots.

    Post a Reply
  54. That same justification was used to strip the native Americans of their land. More Israelis die of fucking peanut allergies than terror attacks the apologetics are pretty fucking flimsy.

    Post a Reply
  55. @Chyson Shuffleburg I guess the obvious has completely flown over your head… The concept of "their land," is a fallacy, in this specific instance as well as in general.

    Post a Reply
  56. No one is gonna stop this take over of the ursurper….. wake up people it's been written for thousands of years…..or talked about…. when all of the world starts shouting peace on earth…..FINALLY, PEACE ON EARTH… then worry…..til then alll these stories are distractions….oh by the way….. have a good night….. continue to sleep through it…..

    Post a Reply
  57. Oceann Lily Johnson they even landmined them carzy stuff the head piggy on that one just got a big promotion recently too.

    Post a Reply
  58. I think if mexico and china may take over the USA one day, and we hope not to hear you americans whine about anyting then when they stick you guys all delaware.

    Post a Reply
  59. MSNBC has no backbone! So disappointed in Kats Snow and Martin Fletcher, and above all at MSNBC, the network of Rachel Maddow — one of my favorites! But, after this fiasco, I'm boycotting MSNBC. Be journalists and report the truth!! The truth is that Israel is a colonialist apartheid regime which took the land on which Palestinians lived for 1200 years, by force. Israel has reneged on Oslo Accord, which President Clinton so painstakingly negotiated, by not only refusing to return land to the Palestinians taken in 1967 war, it has continued to evict Palestinians from West Bank and bulldoze their homes to make room for more illegal settlements. If that wasn't bad enough, it has repeatedly engaged in disproportionate military attacks on Gaza, killing thousands of innocent civilians. Shame on Israel, on US government for indulging this insanity, and on MSNBC for feeding Israeli propaganda to the Americans!!

    Post a Reply
  60. Simone Uomorosso Look, The Jewish people originally lived in this area of land. They rebelled against God and were removed from being a nation and were scattered to the winds. Other people groups moved in and have lived there for a significant period of time. America and the Natives are sort of a similar comparison. The jews are like the natives in that they were there first, but for the Native Americans to wage war and force the non-natives into restricted territories would be to ignore that after they were fucked with, many American families with no direct involvement lived in the area. You end up with 2 people groups with a claim to the land. The 'palestinians' are ethnically Arab/Jordanian, and there have been opportunities for two states, but the Islamic religion which demands Jewish extermination, as they are decended from 'pigs and apes' is a big problem. The figures negotiating with the Jewish, Israelis don't really want peace, nor do they wish to help their own people. Israel is not perfect, but they are not the devils they are made out to be. I am an American who largely depises my own government; I believe the Jewish people have a right to their homeland, but not at the expense of another people group, and there are many many Jews who wish to live in haramony. The Israeli government, with all it's imperfections, has been more willing to establish two states than the Palestinian government. You can't argue flattly against either side or deny the human rights of either people group.

    Post a Reply
  61. It's saddening to me how so many people sympathize so much with Native Americans and even Palestinians who are not living on the same land as them, yet nobody here says anything about paying reparations to the descendents of the 1 billion plus Diaspora Africans who were murdered and brutally forced to build the supposed free world that were living in today during chattel slavery. NOBODY even hints at the amount of land, adding up to the of the entire U.S., being brutally taken from Africans during the Greek, Roman, British, and Arab conquests, on top of the continued slavery thereafter and the disproportionate black prison population in this nation. Why is the largest genocide and continued disenfranchising of blacks world wide always swept under the rug. But when somebody brings it up, insensitive responses of, "what does that have to do b with this", insue. IT HAS EVERYTHING TO DO WITH THIS IF YOU KNOW WHY THIS PALESTINIAN ARAB AGENDA IS BEING PROPAGATED THROUGH MEDIA.

    Post a Reply
  62. Israel has absolutely no intention of allowing for Palestinian state and the Palestinians will soon become the ethnic minority population of the state of Israel.

    Post a Reply
  63. But it is "our fucking land" now that we killed off and imprisoned any person that was here first

    Post a Reply
  64. Yes the Jewish people did not occupy that land thousands of years ago,yes that land was not promised to them by the father,yes they were not driven from there land only to return to find it occupied by the thousands of muslims who were driven from there lands!!!!as it pretains to native Americans,you do realize that even the American Indians migrated here,they were not from here,walked thousands of years thru land bridges,to get here and most kept moving,so to say this was the American Indians land alone is bullshit,nobody had claim here!!!!so stop with your liberal eye for an eye,o it must be true so we must punish you,grow up!!!!

    Post a Reply
  65. Right and wrong , good and bad , fair and unfair rarely influence the outcome of these things. It all comes down to who has the most guns.

    Post a Reply
  66. The reason behind Israel/Palestine conflict is the need of western allies to control the access from Mediterranean Sea to Persian Gulf.

    Post a Reply
  67. American Jew to defend Palestine and Israel attacking http://www.optim-web.com Jewish writer Norman Finkelstein describes the Holocaust crying tears of crocodiles http://normanfinkelstein.com
    …………………………………………………………………………………………………………
    Moreover, 93% of Jews are Jews O_kanz their origin back to the State of the Caspian, which ruled by Tsarist Russia and origin nomads and pagans converted to Judaism after the founding of their state in the seventh century at the hands of their king Bolan, who chose Judaism have officially of his kingdom and ordered his people Batnagah .. . After eliminating state migrated many of them divided into Europe and then America has been to Palestine after the creation of the World Zionist and that the state of Israel founded the Balfour Declaration was specifically in their name are the Rothschild family German Alkhozrah origin, who through Israel aspire to rule the whole world after the completion of their project as Global System New …………….. it intended that of all the Jews who Anagareethm today are the big lie they are not of the children of Israel and the Jews of the Hebrews did not be present one day in the land of Palestine are originally Bedouins gone from bloody savages pagans were always raiding around them and live Hbathm as it was the Mongols to murder and pillage and extermination of other peoples around them ………. For the Holocaust are also planned and burned their own people in order to propitiation world and subjugate Europe for their orders and there are many videos confessed that it and the strangest thing is that they were in America spread by more than ten years in the newspapers about the Holocaust and request assistance and facilities for immigration to Palestine Bsabbha from the date of the outbreak of World War II .. and everything else admitted many Jews also that he had told them that Palestine is a land without a people and were surprised after their migration to their state they lied because they neither they nor their parents nor their grandparents who were the North Caucasus set foot on the land of Palestine, or they know nothing about it .. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dda -0Q_XUhk …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tE7S4uYAEAs
    Google

    Post a Reply
  68. American Jew to defend Palestine and Israel attacking http://www.optim-web.com Jewish writer Norman Finkelstein describes the Holocaust crying tears of crocodiles http://normanfinkelstein.com
    …………………………………………………………………………………………………………
    Moreover, 93% of Jews are Ashkenazi Jews of their origin back to the State of the Caspian (Khazar), which ruled by Tsarist Russia and origin nomads and pagans converted to Judaism after the founding of their state in the seventh century at the hands of their king Bolan, who chose Judaism have officially of his kingdom and ordered his people Batnagah .. . After eliminating state migrated many of them divided into Europe and then America has been to Palestine after the creation of the World Zionist and that the state of Israel founded the Balfour Declaration was specifically in their name are the Rothschild family German Alkhozrah origin, who through Israel aspire to rule the whole world after the completion of their project as Global System New …………….. it intended that of all the Jews who Anagareethm today are the big lie they are not of the children of Israel and the Jews of the Hebrews did not be present one day in the land of Palestine are originally Bedouins gone from bloody savages pagans were always raiding around them and live Hbathm as it was the Mongols to murder and pillage and extermination of other peoples around them ………. For the Holocaust are also planned and burned their own people in order to propitiation world and subjugate Europe for their orders and there are many videos confessed that it and the strangest thing is that they were in America spread by more than ten years in the newspapers about the Holocaust and request assistance and facilities for immigration to Palestine Bsabbha from the date of the outbreak of World War II .. and everything else admitted many Jews also that he had told them that Palestine is a land without a people and were surprised after their migration to their state they lied because they neither they nor their parents nor their grandparents who were the North Caucasus set foot on the land of Palestine, or they know nothing about it .. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dda -0Q_XUhk …………………………………………………………………………………………………….. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tE7S4

    Post a Reply
  69. Lol you all. Map does not shows sinnai peninsula, israel got from egypt and gave them back, nor the golan heights they returned to syria.

    Also it does not mention, that before israel, most of those belonged to jordan and egypt, but no jews were involved then, so noone shouted that palestinian muslims want their country..

    Anyway, before you judge – come to the region and learn to ubderstand the conflict

    Post a Reply
  70. Interestingly, we fought Great Britain, we won, we kept the land as spoils of war. We fought Mexico, we won, we kept the land as spoils of war. Examples can be found across the globe. Throughout history, to the victor goes to spoils. Arabs started an ill-conceived war in 1967 as they were unhappy with the UN boundries. They lost, miserably. Israel won, they keep the land as spoils of war. Seems pretty simple and historically sound.

    Post a Reply
  71. Darren Mulholland I remember years ago reading that one of the leaders of Israel admitted that the treatment of the Palestinian "problem" was based almost completely on the way white people did away with the Native Americans.

    Post a Reply
  72. One thing people don't realize is that 50% of Israeli Jews are Ashkenazi Jews, and the most recent DNA research proves that at least 80% of Ashkenazi DNA is white European, with absolutely no link whatsoever to the middle east. None. Israel is a white colony of white people who have stolen the land of people descended from the indigenous populations of the middle east. It is absolutely disgusting that anyone would defend this.

    Post a Reply
  73. Grady Phillips A) 50% of Jewish citizens – the Jews who claim Israel as their "homeland" – are Ashkenazi Jews, who have been proven with modern DNA evidence to be descended from Europe. They have literally no genetic link to the middle east, and are NOT descended from the ancient Hebrews. So yeah, you can argue flatly against a pack of white colonists who have stolen the land of thousands of innocent human beings and forced them to live in squalor and apartheid. Sephardic Jews – who are actually descended from the middle east – lived in Palestine for hundreds of years, mostly without incident. It was the founding of this brutal apartheid regime and the subsequent land theft that decimated the lives of the Palestinian people that caused this.

    Finally, Israel has NEVER been willing to offer the Palestinians a contiguous state, and this is the issue. They want Palestine broken up into little pieces, surrounded by Israel, with travel controlled by Israeli soldiers as it is now. They want Palestine to have no right to control of its own airspace. They are basically offering nothing other than the "right" to call a bunch of little broken up territories "Palestine," while continuing to deny these people a reasonable state in one piece.

    Post a Reply
  74. Except it is 100% illegal to hold land taken in war. But fuck it, right? I mean, "the Holocaust," so Israel can violate pretty much every single international law on the books.

    Post a Reply
  75. Sorry, your genocide against indiginous Americans was 25 000 000+, there are barely none left to give your homes back to. The millions of Palestinian people are there in the region right now and are having their homes buldozed daily by the Jewish migrants who are recent and current arrivals. Hardly comparable.

    Post a Reply
  76. What you're really saying is " they didn't have a military so they don't have any claim. Might makes right."

    Post a Reply
  77. Let me correct this that map is and will never be the truth. Israel has proposes many twoo state solutions. We handed over gaza to the palistinians and contrantly work towards peace. We are tired of burrying our chikdren and im sure the palistinians are. Israel gains dothing from the current situation but PA gains billions. Why is it Abbas is worth 1.5 billion and always walks away from peace talks when any progress is made? Because he bank rolls the suffering of his own people. Who dont have basic services (garbage etc.) they dont use any of their international aid money on helping themselves and the fencing off of their lands has been a response to decades of terror attacks on civilians. The palistinians worst enemy is their own leadership. And also look at the history of it like seriously look. Much lamd was given to the arabs 80% of what was given to the jews by the balfor declaration was handed over to arabs. They tell the west they want their own plave to be at peace and tell their people to kill all jews to drive us to the see and spill every drop of jewish blood. Their leadership doesnt want peace and they use oppression and the radicalization of their people to braimwashing them into attacking israel for no reward. Half the israeli jews are jews that were orginally from arabs countries and forced out under penalty of death. Even if we do give over all of the country to arabs. Where do the expatriated arab jews go? We are so tollerant we will tollerate the extermination of the jews because ots apart of the sunni culture? What that fuck is that honestly

    Post a Reply
  78. That's just racist nonsense as most multi national corporations including banks are owned by millions of shareholders. If you're going to blame anyone for Capitalism then you might as well blame the Scottish as Adam Smith the father of Capitalist ideology was a Protestant Scotsman. You might as well blame the Jews for Socialism as it's founding fathers were Jewish seeking a world of fairness and equality.

    Post a Reply
  79. Simone Uomorosso Don't be ridiculous, it was not a British colony it was a mandate as Lebannon was mandated to France. Nobody claims there were no Lebanese. However, there is no denying that large numbers of Palestinians are the descendents of Jews who converted to Christianity and Islam, while large numbers of Israeli's are Europeans with 1.5m of them recent Russian migrants.

    Post a Reply
  80. Chyson Shuffleburg Yes, and as much as I personally disagree, that is the way of the world. Nevertheless in this particular scenario there were extremely reasonably opportunitites afforded the "Palestinians," opportunitites they squandered.

    Post a Reply
  81. Then a simple solution would be to give the Palestinian people Israeli citizenship as they are the original inhabitants that still live there in large numbers. Your failed argument would also then deny the people of Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Kuwait,Jordan,Bahrain, UAE…..the right to call themselves a nationality as they were also under the control of the Ottoman and other empires. The U.N. mandated the creation of an Israeli state who's borders were clearly defined. The Israeli state has ilegally disregarded these borders and continued to expand into territory it has no right legally in international accepted law to occupy. Quite simple and clear!!

    Post a Reply
  82. It was the Israeli's that attacked and the Israeli's that are in contravention of international law. There's no argument just fact.

    Post a Reply
  83. Robin Behan My argument isn't failed, it is reality and the Palestinians are losing.

    There has never been a nation of Palestine, unlike Syria, Iraq, etc..Your Ottoman point holds no water.

    The UN mandate assumed Palestinina acceptance of the terms. they did not, and the Israeli's did, therefore they are not bound or obligated in any way.

    The Palestininas have shit all over many good offers because they simply don't believe the Jews should be allowed to exist in Israel.

    Post a Reply
  84. That's just Zionist propaganda as there are Jewish communities admitedly small still in most Arab countries and in Iran there are Jews elected to their parlimant.

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *